Sunday, December 7, 2008

Question

This may really random, but I've been thinking a lot about book endings. Many were disappointed with the ending of Breaking Dawn since everything was settled peacefully. And many were happy with the end of Harry Potter with the huge fight.
So I've been thinking. Would people rather have a love story that ends with
1)the main character ending up with the guy she met at the beginning of the story
OR
2)the guy who she used to be friends with and dated for a little while, whose heart she broke.
The first guy she met after moving to a new school. He kisses her once and she can only compare it to the one guy she has kissed before so she thinks its amazing. They are good friends but nothing may come out of it if they don't want to.
The second guy is one whom she had gone out with a couple times but nothing amounted from it since she moved. He was in a band and after she moves she hears the band on a station that wants to play local talent (they still live in the same region, just apart and he has no clue where she is) play a song by his band. Throughout the entire song he whispers her name in the background (so heart breaking).
The final decision comes at prom night and she needs to choose.
So which you you perfer to read? And which one do you think is the more over used one?

3 comments:

AD said...

Hmmmm....I'm on the fence.

I've always liked the endings where the girl ends up with the guys she met at the beginning of the story.
:]

Why, are you writing a novel we don't know about?
:D

Anonymous said...

Guy in the band for sure!But there has to be a fight between the two guys or something. Crash the prom!lol! That'd make the story exciting...then again maybe that's just me =)

Ammietia (a girl you once knew) said...

I like tragedy. And i think the song thing is cheesy xD. Something you would only find cute in books, eye-rollable in real life.

oh and i love big huge fights and conflict and all that.

ignore lack of capitals or any spelling mistakes, finger got smushed and i cannot type.